image 28

#AskAlan, Vol. 63

With (many) final thoughts on a memorable Masters

By Alan Shipnuck
April 12, 2023

I used to dislike Jon Rahm because he couldn’t control his temper and he’d blow up. That’s changed. Different guy now. What happened? @gwgmtweets

He grew up, and into a golfing gentleman who oozes class and even a certain regal vibe. Rahm is only 28, but he already feels like an elder statesman. He is remarkably eloquent and deep…in his second language. Golf is very lucky to have him as an ambassador.

Should we expect Phil to actually compete in LIV events now or was this just another flash in the pan like the 2021 PGA? @VeryAvgDad

One school of thought on Mickelson’s resurgence at Augusta is that he finally arrived at a tournament that inspires him to care. That ain’t it. I’ve observed Phil at numerous LIV events, and he has never worked harder. Certainly his new level of fitness shows that as well. He has struggled on LIV not because he doesn’t care but for the opposite reason: He’s getting in his own way. I think this Masters performance will free him up and unlock some good golf.

Does success at the Masters change our tune on guys like Phil and Brooks? For Phil specifically, does this allow us to forgive and forget? They say winning solves most problems, and this sure felt like a win for Phil. @StueyStats

It’s always hard to write about Mickelson without invoking Tiger Woods. Consider what Tiger has put the game (and his family) through over the last 13 years with scandal and self- destructive behavior, but ever since he won the 2019 Masters he has never been more beloved. What has Phil been guilty of? Greed, sure, but that’s most golfers these days. Sneakiness, bad judgment, hubris…yes, but again, none of these things compare to Tiger’s indiscretions. It will always be a thrill to see Phil in full flight, as he was on the back nine at Augusta National. He remains a transcendent talent and consummate performer. Judging by the roars that followed him on Sunday, I think fans are ready to embrace him again.

How good would TW be if he asked for an accommodation and took a cart for majors? #AskAlan @garyrind

This is suddenly golf’s most tantalizing hypothetical. It does seem like Tiger is still effective at delivering the clubface to the back of the ball, despite his many physical restrictions. He has shown flashes of his old brilliance with his short game and putting. He has impressive clubhead speed with the driver. But I’m not sure I buy Woods’s contention that he is the same golfer and the rigors of walking hilly courses is the only thing holding him back. He hit a ton of loose shots at the Masters before withdrawing. In the first round, when the weather was perfect and Woods was at his freshest, he made five bogeys and shot 74 on a soft course in easy conditions. Even before mangling his right leg in the 2021 car crash, Woods had an injury history that included a fused spine, a rebuilt knee, a frayed Achilles, a ruptured ACL and various other dings. Now, how much can he prepare for the rigors of tournament golf, even at home in a cart? If he could ride instead of walk, maybe Woods would play eight to 10 tournaments a year instead of four to five, but would that be enough to get/remain sharp and tangle with young, hungry, confident, fully optimized megatalents? Woods in a cart would surely be a more dangerous player but I think only occasionally. 

image 29

How do you assess Rory’s game after another missed cut at a major? It seems like mentally he’s still in a 

good place, even if his game isn’t. @tj_snell

I’m not sure the physical or mental aspect is particularly strong right now, given that McIlroy also missed the cut at the Players. He hit a lot of hooks off the tee at Augusta National, which is always a warning sign. And his utter capitulation was dispiriting in the extreme. Rory will find it again, but this Masters left a bruise.

#AskAlan Koepka won’t call him out, but did Patrick Cantlay and his atrocious pace of play cause Brooks a shot at the jacket? Not saying Brooks would have won but gotta think the multiple waits didn’t allow a quick player to find his groove. @EddieK619

One of the pleasures of this Masters was that it united all the warring tribes of Golf Twitter into an unusual consensus: everyone hates Patrick Cantlay. At Hilton Head this week, Cantlay offered a defense of his slow play, blaming the course, the greens, the wind, major championship pressure…basically everything but Patrick Cantlay his own self, which is obviously part of the problem here. But Rahm was playing alongside Koepka and he didn’t let the ordeal derail his concentration. Unfortunately, Cantlay is right, in that slow play is now just part of championship golf, so if you want to prevail you have to learn to overcome it.

Why won’t ANGC enforce pace of play rules unless it’s a 14-year-old Asian kid? @M_Sand09

It goes back to the weird vibe of the Masters, in which the green jackets have absolute power and everyone else is an invited guest. Tournament officials have an almost patronizing attitude toward the players, and penalizing them is considered bad manners. That’s how Tiger escaped a DQ in 2013, Ernie Els got a free drop in the middle of a forest, Rory was allowed to skate on testing the sand and Brooks didn’t get a penalty this year despite very damning video evidence. The green jackets simply don’t want to put a damper on their party. The penalty given to 14-year-old Guan Tianlang in 2013 was handed out by John Paramor, the famously imperious European Tour referee who was out there freelancing, much to the chagrin of Masters officials. 

Is OWGR officially outdated for the majors? @ChuckNorris1369

Well, a four-time major championship winner who had won two of his last six starts came in ranked 118th in the world so, yeah, the exclusion of LIV players is looking increasingly silly. There was already pressure on the OWGR to find a solution to rank every player, which is part of its mission statement. After this Masters, that feels like a mandate.

What does this Masters do to the civil war in golf? (Feels to me like maybe it mellows the feud out a bit, but what do I know.) @PeteViles

I think you’re right. The good cheer and even camaraderie between most LIV golfers and Tour loyalists was a welcome development after the bitchiness of last year. The strong play of the LIV crew earned them some grudging respect, and from the beginning, Rahm has been a conciliatory voice calling for compromise. His victory gives him an even bigger platform. So all in all, it was a good week for those who hope to see the game get put back together again.

#AskAlan Is it fair to say that Rory might not win another major? Crazy to think both Tiger and Phil have won one since Rory’s last. @Dannykowalski22

It’s a crazy thought…but fair. He has played at an exceptionally high level over the last nine years but obviously has a mental block in the majors. The tougher, more exacting setups in the majors also expose McIlroy’s weakness: He’s 172nd in strokes gained putting and 185th in proximity on approaches from 125 to 150 yards. You would think a major will just fall into his lap at some point, but it refuses to happen. Only a handful of players in golf history have gone 10 years or more between major championship victories. McIlroy better hustle.

Cameron Young — future #1? @frazerrice

Well, he should probably win a tournament first: The dude is oh-fer-38! Young has a spectacular long game but ranks 183rd in strokes gained putting, which would explain his inability to win. I think he will have a long, successful career, but the putting will have to improve if Young is ever going to sniff No. 1.

image 30

#AskAlan Is Viktor Hovland the most overrated player in golf? It feels like he receives an outsized amount of attention compared to what he’s accomplished, which is relatively little. @the_agrippa

Well, he’s a delightful human and a great looking guy who wears clothes very well, no matter how gaudy they might be. So he brings a certain star quality beyond the results. At 25, Hovland has three PGA Tour wins at B-list events plus two quality victories in Europe and two dubs at Tiger’s Hero Challenge, which features a strong, albeit small, field. So he’s off to a good start! I wouldn’t call him a star, just a very good player. Hovland has now contended in his last two major championships, which is obviously encouraging. I don’t think he’s overrated but perhaps a tiny bit overhyped. Some strong wins will fix that.

Did the Masters brief the press on being respectful as to asking questions about LIV vs. PGA Tour? @JStewGolf

No, nothing like that. But a rotating cast of Augusta National members serve as moderators for the press conferences, and I believe a couple go out of their way not to call on me no matter how vigorously I wave my hand. That’s a more subtle way of accomplishing what you’re asking about.

#askalan. Someone said on air that after the win Rahm would have dinner with the members. I’ve never heard this. Do they have a meet-and-greet buffet, or what? @SusanSSL

Yes, it’s a quaint tradition for the champ and his family to dine with the membership in a special pavilion next to the clubhouse built just for the occasion. When Zach Johnson won in ’07 I followed him into the dinner and it was quite a sight to see 100 or more green jackets. Unlike the Tuesday night Champions Dinner, the club handles the menu (lobster macaroni and cheese is a perennial favorite) and covers the cost. But after his breakthrough win in 2004, Mickelson pulled aside then chairman Hootie Johnson. “He was so overjoyed to have won he really wanted to celebrate,” says Phil’s wife, Amy, “so he tells Hootie, ‘Go deep in the wine cellar and pull out your best stuff.’” Augusta National’s cellar is legendary and has been widely described as among the best in the world. A particular favorite among the green jackets is Château Lafite Rothschild, a Bordeaux of which some vintages can retail for up to $15,000 a bottle. “Phil got pulled away, and after he was gone I heard Hootie say to another club official, ‘Do be sure that Mr. Mickelson is presented the bill for the wine.’”

#AskAlan Mickelson, McIlroy, Speith… Who wins the Grand Slam first? I think Spieth. He’s playing great, and the PGA is the easiest to win. @LaBeets50

I agree with your line of thinking, but Oak Hill is a tight, brawny, penal old-school design that seems ill-suited to Jordan’s erratic play. Meanwhile, LACC is a non-traditional U.S. Open venue that will reward iron play and a creative short game, two of Mickelson’s strengths. So Phil has an advantage in the short-term, but if he doesn’t pull another rabbit out of the hat this year I think Spieth is the answer, because Rory’s Augusta jinx appears to be metastasizing. 

You are Greg Norman for a moment: Are you happy or devastated about what happened at the Masters?

#askalan @RealTurtleBR

If I’m Greg Norman for a moment, I’m definitely going grocery shopping in bicycle shorts, which I don’t normally do. Per the Masters, he has to be elated as the strong showing of the LIV players gives the circuit a needed shot of credibility. But Norman also has to be wistful of what could have been because Koepka winning would have been a monumental marketing opportunity for LIV. On the whole, they’ll take it.

8 thoughts on “#AskAlan, Vol. 63”

  1. This Masters had all kinds of interesting story lines, for sure. Including Rory’s poor performance. But a bigger story line seems to have developed after the tournament, when Rory WD’s from the RBC Heritage.

    Rory has been the “lead horse” in developing this schedule/ format of “elevated” events, which clearly hurts those further down in the rankings, but now he WD’s out of his 2nd “elevated” event in only 6 such events. If Rory is not going to be beholden to the system he has advocated, why did he put so much effort into bringing it to fruition? I like Rory and feel he has been a very good (excellent!) spokesman for the PGA Tour during the LIV Golf debacle, but this WD is very troubling.

  2. I think folks are exaggerating the impact that Brooks’ and Phil’s performances at the Masters will have on the future of LIV golf. Yes, there are some championship caliber golfers on the LIV tour who will do well in the four majors, but that does not elevate LIV as a golf tour that most people will have even the slightest curiosity about. Last year controversy reigned, and so LIV got a lot of attention in the media. This year it’s just another obscure sports league like the WNBA or the NASL. Outside of maybe a handful of golfers, most of the LIV participants are has beens or nobodies. The LIV team concept is a joke. I defy anyone to name even 3 LIV teams. Finally, their tournaments are televised on a network that, again, no one has heard of. LIV golf is dead.


      Agree 100%. I will take it a step further and say The Masters was a complete failure for LIV.

      It’s 3 show horse performances came from (1) Patrick Reed, hands down the most hated, cheating, uncharismatic golfer on any tour, (2) Phil, who looks unhealthy to the point of resembling a tanned Ghoul who now rarely speaks, and when he does either spouts irrelevant bromides or thinly veiled attacks at everyone he hates (his post round comments were choice, where he threw barbs at Bones and Tiger) – not sure which is worse, and (3) Koepka, who essentially admitted he would rather be back on tour and when the chips were down experienced one of the great, historic capitulations over the Weekend at The Masters.

      This is not what Norman and The Saudis wanted.

  3. Hey Alan! Great stuff, per usual.

    Question: I see Liv And Let Die (great title!) comes out on Halloween. As this is a developing story, I’m curious as to when you have to put down your pencil and turn in your final work? Unless you‘ve had to already?


    How can you not love a player like Hovland? He is getting closer and closer to a meaningful breakthrough I hope. Some of his shirts are questionable, but he is like a breath of fresh air in my view. He seems to be having a great time 90% of the time. Love the story about him essentially driving all over the country in his SUV from tournament to tournament just out of Okie State. Love to see him have a great year.

  5. Jim Nance saying they didn’t ace Mickelson out of coverage is totally disingenuous. Did anyone else notice you did not see Phil (or any other LIV masters champion) in the CBS promos. But I guess this is to be expected given the huge stake Viacom has in the PGA tour success. Just please don’t insult our intelligence and say it wasn’t the case. It was plain as day.

  6. Alan, in this same issue as Ask Alan #64 (next issue) Michael issues an impassioned plea for golf to follow rules and traditions in his Reflections on the Masters piece and not gloss over the egregious behaviour of Koepka and his caddy. How can you so blithly say “Oh, LIV golfers should be given OWGR points when they don’t follow the OWGR rules?? Is it because you went to a few exhibitions and have a book coming out on LIV? Very, very disappointing.

    I for one see the Masters as a one time anomoly for LIV golfers. They know the course, Koepka got the best weather Thursday and Friday and Phil was 10 shots back and free wheeling the last 18…..just like Rory last year. Koepka shows what happens when you don’t play 72, losing by 7 to Rahm the last 18. As for Cantley, he is so self absorbed and uncaring of any other opinion than his, he could fit right in the NBA.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *